Welcome back to the wasteland!
We're neck deep in fall and the weather has finally been shifting accordingly. I have to say, it's nice to finally be rid of all that heat. Now here's hoping we don't get winter charging in early again this year. I need more comfortable weather in this wasteland for once.
That aide, let us get into it.
Today's subject is a bit of an odd one, so I hope you can stick with me on it. I wanted to talk about the over the top self-consciousness these online spaces have been run on for too long, and how we can finally move on from this tired frame. The larger issue is that this shift goes back rather far, and who even knows if it can be dealt with at this point, before the internet finally implodes upon itself. Nonetheless, I'd like to give it a try.
So let's get to it and talk about "Cringe" and self-seriousness. Where did all of this come from, and why does it persist?
A lot has changed since the early days of the internet, though it isn't as if it's ever really stayed the same for very long either. The state it is in today, however, is rather dire. A lot of the sites and mechanisms that defined those days have been dying at higher and higher rates. Little remains of what it once was. Not only that, the old social media is also waning, YouTube and Twitch are falling apart, search engines are useless, and bots flood everything. We are a long way from where we began, and we can't ever go back there again, no matter how much we might want it.
Also, now Millennials ('90s babies and '00s kids, I'm not referring to Gen Y's '80s babies and '90s kids) are now at the point where they are old enough to realize what they've lost and how they got to where they are today. As many, including myself, have said: there is no mass nostalgic movement for the '00s, because not only has little changed from that era culturally (or is degraded from it), but the last of the monoculture tapered off in that very decade. It's hard to be nostalgic for SpongeBob, Evanescence, and Marvel movies, when they still exist.
However, the above video is worth the watch for those who think they remember that decade, but probably don't. Not only was it very different back then in a lot of ways, but there has been a lot of revisionism, even at that very time, that retroactively declared a lot of things "cringe" and embarrassing that no one thought was such at the time. The video uses the Nostalgia Critic and Channel Awesome for the subject, and it is probably the perfect example of how the idea of "cringe" has ruined cultural expression.
The creator of the video was clearly a '90s baby who grew up in the '00s, as he discusses his experience dealing with the site and its creators as a child, and its through his perspective that we get a more honest interpretation of what it was like at the time compared to later revisionism from those embarrassed about their "cringe" past of online entertainment consumption would have you believe. No one was shying away for their love of the Nostalgia Critic in 2008. In fact a lot of the same people mocking him today were eagerly consuming his content back then. What changed? The desire to be taken seriously overtook their sense of whimsy.
What I mean by this is that for a long time now there has been a full scale court press to make fun of these "embarrassing" old videos of "hacks" who took themselves "too seriously" and how ridiculous it was that anyone ever enjoyed this stuff in the first place. But the as the above video shows, most of that is an overcorrection to what the initial reaction to this stuff was.
The fact of the matter is a lot of this kind of thing was new in the '00s, and one of the few examples of the last shreds of the monoculture that had, unknowingly to everyone, already been shredded to pieces. We watched this stuff primarily because we could bond over it, and we still had the shared culture language to be able to discuss it without heavy irony, sarcasm, and Good Guy/ Bad Guy dehumanization.
Unfortunately, that world is long gone now, and much of the revisionism today is to cover up that it ever existed in the first place. It's more obsessing over "cringe" instead of expressing the truth that we've lost the connection and have no interest in regaining it.
The truth is that no one took this stuff seriously back then. They were fun reviews by tongue in cheek over the top personalities cribbing off the entertainment of the 1980s and '90s. They were meant to be silly videos to make you laugh using what was thought of as popular opinions from the Gen Y crowd who grew up on most of the material covered in them. Popular opinion might be different now (though nowhere near as widespread as it was then), but in a world that wants us to pretend Captain Planet was anything but a punchline back in the day to excuse modern hack writing, much of this era probably needs to be preserved just so we can avoid the constant attempts at revisionism by the modern crowd who controls the discourse over this stuff today.
It was a very different time. We need to remember why that was, instead of hiding from it out of cowardice of what we'll find.
Channel Awesome's first movie "Kickassia" was beloved when it came out in 2010. Watch the above video to get more of the context and even why it works despite what "conventional" wisdom has said on it in the more irony poisoned and embarrassed internet that quickly followed its release. It was a simple special made for the anniversary of the site in question that highlights the talents that worked there, with the same typical over the top crude humor that was popular at the time and in their videos. It's simple and straightforward, and does exactly what it was trying to do.
So why did its reputation change? It is due to the rise of "cringe" as the worst thing you can be. Putting yourself out there, risking doing something unpopular or new, became standard not long after its release. The 2010s, if its defined by anything, will be that turn of celebrating stepping into line, saying the popular slogans the people in charge tell you to say, clean up your opinions and language (and sound like everyone else, of course), and don't dare stray from the new norm the Good People tell you to uphold. As a consequence, the older ways were now verboten, outdated, and maybe even offensive to the new order that came into existence five seconds ago. Not doing what you were supposed was now "cringe" no matter how authentic it might have been to you. This meant the old stuff had to be buried, and it was.
But back in the day, no one cared about being "cringe" at all. It was not even a consideration. If your view was unpopular, that was okay. Make your case, or don't, and you would get confronted over it and have to defend whatever you upheld. Maybe you'd change your view, maybe not, but dialogue would happen. It went off kilter when Nu Atheism reared its sneering head (the first real shot in cultural cohesion of the time period), among other events which firmly closed the book on any possibility of coming together.
And that it is what the 2010s were: destruction. The loss of a monoculture meant that the connection was severed, and now the modern climate is run by a bunch of outdated factions fighting for control over a landscape none of them can stand to share with each other anymore. It's Good team vs Bad team and nothing else.
This might be why the "early internet" (really just the '00s era) is about the one thing from the 2000s that has really stuck around in people's minds. It truly was a "wild west" because it was full of people who treated it as one. Now because we've so tightly tied it down that atmosphere has been lost. What remains is fakeness, posing and posturing.
The sense of fun and whimsy, and the idea of communication through culture, has been lost. And what were we left with? Hyper serious scolds who can't enjoy anything.
Here's a shorter video about this trend:
Now, don't me wrong, I don't like the '00s. I've been very straight with that for a long time now. There was plenty wrong about the era, and full embracement of Cringe actually was a problem. It meant no one could take anything seriously, which led to the over correction to come. Everything was a big joke and nothing mattered at all.
The actual answer to this quandary is balance. We need to have the fearlessness to not care about being Cringe, but also the self-awareness and tact to know when to be serious. We need to reclaim standards and function as a society again where we put things as they should be. We can't have one or the other: we need both.
That will probably only happen when a new monoculture is formed again after whatever bottom we're due to hit. Until then its only going to get angrier, stiffer, and more bitter, out there. There's no escaping decline.
However, we also don't need to be a part of that. We can still create, we can still be Cringe, we can still be serious, and we can still communicate with each other our wants and desires. We don't have to be trapped like this, and we don't have to play along with people who hate and want to destroy us. We can strive to be normal.
I'm not telling you that you have to like Kickassia, because it's definitely not for everyone, but at least understand why people did and still do. That is the first step to understanding. We can't keep hating the past forever, even if its just silly stuff like a throwaway special for an old internet comedy site. It's the silly stuff that makes the world go round.
As for me, I still have the City Eater Kickstarter starting soon, and I just had a story release in the new Relics Anthology! My story is called "Bad Town" and is about a grudge spanning time and space that brings a bunch of kids into an old conflict between greasers. What is it that brought them here, and what is it they need to finally settle the score? Check it out here!
But I'm just one person. There are plenty of people creating out there, forging means of connection and more. This is just a single example.
It all starts small, anyway. Refusing to be scared of being Cringe is just one simple step. But, hey, it may be enough for what we need. Only one way to find out.












